Two very different conversations about business storytelling struck me today.
The first was Seth Godin’s post about the rational marketer (and the irrational customer):
The most common frustration I see, and I see it daily, comes from marketers who can’t figure out why more people won’t buy their product…Let’s say, for example, that you have a service that can deliver leads for five percent of what it costs to get them via a trade show. Why would any rational business, particularly one that says it wants qualified leads, spend that money on trade shows and not on you?…The problem is that your prospect doesn’t care about any of those things. He cares about his boss or the story you’re telling or the risk or the hassle of making a change.
The second was from a New York Times article about vitamins. It quoted a scientist who couldn’t understand why people buy vitamins (when study after study shows no positive effect from taking them).
I’m puzzled why the public in general ignores the results of well-done trials,’” said Dr. Eric Klein, national study coordinator for the prostate cancer trial and chairman of the Cleveland Clinic’s Glickman Urological and Kidney Institute. “’The public’s belief in the benefits of vitamins and nutrients is not supported by the available scientific data. (NY Times 2/17/09)
emotional business storytelling beats logic
The cold, hard dull facts may be truthful, but they’re not emotionally engaging. Don’t give statistics, tell a business story instead.
Vitamin-takers (and prospects) don’t care what the studies say or how logical it is to skip the trade show and spend money on a different method of lead generation.
What they do care about it is how they feel about it. They “feel better” taking the vitamins. It doesn’t matter what the science says; the emotional payout is higher from taking the pills, plus it’s easier than changing your diet.
Going to the tradeshow is easier too, especially if it’s what you’ve always done. Switching to a different lead generation method is hard. It takes work and it takes time to start working.
Emotional stories get more sales
Tell your prospects a story about how well your lead generation program worked for other customers: Customer XYZ started with three leads a month, struggling to stay afloat; after hiring us it was up to 10 per week. Now, they can make payroll easily every week, and they’re opening two new offices.
Focus on the emotional toll of the wrong solution, and then explain the feel-good payoff of the better choice. Describe how your solution cuts your customers’ stress, or let’s them go home earlier, or may get them a raise.